Meeting with Kat, Saturday 24 October 2026 (Facebook live)

← All talks

24 October 2026 · 1 h 32 min · Kat's Facebook page

This transcript was made by speech-recognition software, so names and some words may be misheard. The recording is the original: watch on Facebook.

Oh. Okay, so we have here with us on Zoom for now, we have Heyman, Emmanuel, Jane, Laird, and William, yes? I'm sorry, Laird and Valeria, I'm sorry, I'll add the name next time. Valeria. Oh, yes, of course, yes, I see you. I see, absolutely, Laird and Valeria. And we have Emmanuel and William. And William look like John. Yeah, that's my brothers. We look a lot alike. No, no, it's my brother's Zoom. Yeah. Okay. And we have here around, we have Julia, and Joe, and Cliff, Ben, Tony, and Ren, and Michael. And we have picture Bob, and Kat, and Dean. And now, we are throwing India the invitation to give us an introduction.

I'm looking at Julia, but Johnny or anyone here on Zoom is equally welcome. Michael is welcome. Everyone, everyone, Bren, Tony, Ben, Cliffy, Joe, Joe. And we have David joining us on Zoom as well. And of course, Dino is welcome. One day I'll talk him into, maybe the day is today. Nah, it's never today. It's always the next day. Julia, will you? Only for a minute, but I'm not going to babble for long. Look, I'm recording while I'm doing this. Actually, I didn't do that. I don't do shit. That's what we were talking about earlier, so I can just stay with that. One of my friends here was beating herself up for something that she claims to have done.

And I just think that it's really helpful to look at the basic facts that nobody does anything because there isn't anybody here to do anything. We could just start with... See, that's... I mean, I really love it. If you think about it for a moment, you got synapses that are being fired. That's what makes a thought happen, right? I mean, you couldn't have a thought without those synapses firing. Are you firing the synapses or is that just apparently happening? I think it's just happening. So then what makes us think that we're doing the thinking? So nobody does anything. What's doing it all? What's aware of it all?

I think that's the question that we're going to be looking... That we look at, really, is can you actually find it without referring to an image or a story of the past of a me or anything? Actually, can you find it? And we find stories. We can find ideas. We can find seeming evidence or whatever, but it's all looking to some other imaginary moment. There isn't. There isn't even this one. So if you take a look... I just love Bob's pointer of the false cannot stand up to investigation. So when beating up is happening, whether I'm beating up the people who are putting on motorsport park in my town, you know, or myself, or I'm going to fight, you know.

I'm not the doer of the fighting and they're not the doer of that. We're all the action figures. It's all just a play, you know. And when you can zoom out and see it as just shit that's just seemingly... It's a movie. It's quite the movie. It's real 5D, you know. But it takes a bit of the sting away of this idea of a me, doesn't it? You know? When it's seen and this is like, oh, yeah, that's part of the movie too. The taking myself to be the doer. That's all also within the dreaming. But is it here now? Or is it just sort of a story that's now being narrated?

There's no storyteller and there's no story. I don't know what else to say except that I can't babble on as well as other people do for an hour. I'm good at it when I'm chatting one-on-one with people. Like, you know, especially newbies. It's so easy. I can try to pretend that there's no one here. That's right. There's only one here. No excuses now. Who makes an excuse? There you go. There you go. I can throw a question at you if you like. We started just recently, just for fun, just to have a little bit of a variety break. And I'm going to... See how other people would answer the questions that Bob answered?

That's really putting me on the spot. No, no, no. I'm going to make it a little bit easier for you. I was just reviewing the book and welcome another William. I was just reviewing the book lately that I published for Bob's anniversary of passing. And they are key concepts here, which I titled 42 as a joke. You used to live on 42 when you moved to Australia and Bob too. The answer to life and everything. That's as good as it gets in regards to non-duality. Giving anyone any answers whatsoever. Because there are no answers. But they're pointers. So I put out the chapter called 42 being 21 key concepts and key metaphors that Bob used to absolutely love.

So I'll throw a couple or three or four and you can expand on them as if there is only one speaking to itself. So one first one is full stop, obvious one. The second thinking won't get you out. There is no answer in the mind. Three. The undeniable being, the truth of the being. And the four. The person is a mask. Pick any. Pick any. Pick any. The person is a mask. The person is a mask. I like that one too. Because that's like, I mean, I'm just babble a little bit about that. You know. Well, Bob would talk about the personality or that actually comes from the Greek word persona, which means mask.

So the ancients knew this intuitively by even calling it a mask. Person. Mask. It is not what we are. There is an image. I remember like a long time ago realizing, like thinking about my dad and how much I love my dad. And I was like thinking about him and how sweet he was and how funny he was and how cheerful he was and easy going. And then it really dawned on me. I'm like, I'm loving a narrative. Yes. Okay. It's not what he is. I love how it expresses. You know what I mean? I think that I might love that more than I love how Trump expresses.

But that too is like, you know, I do. I'm not coming up with what Mr. Gardato used to say about, you know, love all of it or none of it. So if I would really stretch it, I got to love Trump as much as I love the idea of my dad. It's all an idea anyway. How about? I could hate it too. How about? You, you love even your preferences. Yeah. I can love the preferences or the lack of. I can love, I can love my inability to love. There is nothing to need to do. No, I don't have to do shit. It's all perfect.

Nothing has to be different, including whose name I won't mention again. We'll see. Huh? We'll see. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. Who? Carrie. Yeah. It doesn't. I think that's a game changer though, is you can see that it's all just sort of like, I mean, have you ever, I mean, Kat has argued with me on this one, but I don't know if too many stories of people getting PTSD from a bad dream, you could die in a bad dream. But, but, but we, we, we, yes. So if you could die, couldn't you leave? You could live, you could live and die in a dream. Okay.

You can, you both can happen, but like you, you didn't meet people. So you didn't meet people. Oh no. I mean, I did tell you about the dream I had in Italy. I was in Italy recently and we got like, I was buying into it though. Yeah. It was real. Like, you know, this dream I had, I was renting a house actually. I could love that. It was, I was renting a house in Italy and then I was inviting friends and a friend of a friend was coming, a friend I'd never met. And I didn't buy insurance before I rented this house. And then the dream happened while I was sleeping.

This guy who actually, I didn't know, showed up. Actually, he didn't show up. 12 of his hooligan friends showed up with their children and they were destroying the house and they were pouring large mounds of cat litter on the floor of the house. And I called the police to say, do something, but they were busy giving CPR to a sheep and they couldn't come because they were helping a sheep who ended up dying and they didn't come anyway. And when he showed up, he knocked on the door. I'd just woken up out of this. And I was like, you look like you, I just dropped.

But, but when you, but when you're just coming to you, you could see it. Wait a minute. It never really happened. You know, how silly is that? You know, that, that when it's seen that the dream is, well, what happens to the PTSD? Yeah. You know, I think that, that we don't get so much PTSD when you, when you see that it's never really real, that it doesn't really happen. Yes. But how the, how can you explain now the PTSD in animals? I don't know. I can't explain it in animals. I don't know that they have it. Can you accept that it happens now? Cause I don't know about it in animals.

I've never heard of it in animals. Yeah. Never seen an animal in a shelter that has been traumatized. The animals that were kicked out from the house. But you're labeling that as PTSD. Yeah. Or, or just maybe. Absolutely. It's post-traumatic stress disorder. The animal that can't re-enter the, the normal healthy household. Because it has been, it's all computing system has been upgraded to be constantly in a stress of alert. It takes a year for a dog or cat, or depends on the trauma, to actually get this sort of rewiring, to get enough data in the processor to start computing that it is safe to relax now.

I had to actually rescue a cat like that once. And it took actually over a year before the cat could actually come and lie on my lap. Because it was so severely traumatized and the trauma happened within three weeks. I think that we have an advantage over the animals then. You know, in that we can take a look and see that that's just a story. And cat can't. No, they can't. So that gives him. Cliff was. Yeah. You might, you might have got such an. Yeah. That's, that's the animals have memory. So they're replaying memory. Three minutes. There is. Three minutes, apparently. Cat remembers for three minutes.

But how do you know that? Yeah. That's how the computer, that was the watching of the computer. So that is a consensus reality. But I can only remember three minutes. Sometimes it's right. Yeah. If I'm lucky. Yeah. The thing that we are pointing out is really that we don't know. We don't know. The, the idea of, of, of reaction to the environment is conditioned by the environment. If the environment is safe, the responses, and it's consistently safe. The responses will be consistently safe. If the environment gets hostile, the program gets upgraded. And it started, it starts looking for danger. You know, people who were born in a safe environment and enter the war zone.

I, I speak sometimes with people who actually were escaping from the war zone with a little baby on the, on the lap. Just going through the forest from ex Yugoslavia to, to Germany and, and, you know, safe environment, loving parents, very beautiful, safe. And then suddenly adaptation. And then going through the process of the bio computer, learning survival skills, because it has to. And then finding its own balance again when the safety came along. There is greater intelligence to those machines than we could ever see. And the idea that we have control over it, that we can do something about it, is part of it all.

It, it, yes, it evolves as a part. It's a little different. I'm not, I'm not going to talk about it. I'm wrong in everything that I said. You're not wrong. You just. Yeah. So I'll let you keep going. You're not wrong. See, those investigations are about bringing every single aspect to the picture and landing up with all inclusiveness of it. So, yes, they are probably examples in which your situation with trauma doesn't exist or this are relevant. And there are also situations when it is, when the opposite is relevant. That's the beauty of uncompromisingness of it. It doesn't exclude one example or one position. I think it includes everything.

So you're never wrong. You're never right. There is just one of the, one of the perspectives of the whole. And if it felt like I'm contradicting you, I just wasn't the intention. Yeah. So everyone can bring the opposite. That's the beauty of it. Debate it to bring the opposite. So everything. I think Dean is the best at it. You know, to, to just show the whole kaleidoscope of the, all the colors of that incredible dream. It's you, you want to comment on that? Yeah. I'll comment that there's a couple of hands. Oh yeah. Maybe, maybe they, they're comments. I think, I think Emmanuel was first.

But, but I can't like also, all right. But before we go there, then, you know, there's one, one thing like what's seeing what's going on. So there's, there's just seeing. So like, and, and we've said the synapses are firing and creating thoughts. It is, we, we don't actually know. There's no truth to any, anything that we say in one sense. And yet there's all relatively truths all over the place. So like if, if, if the brain is scanned from, from the viewer, from the scan, like it's seeing synapses. There's no, there's no experience of synapses in any, there's experience of a feeling or a thought, all different perspectives, all different viewing points of describing this really.

And, you know, without an analysis or without any thought about it, like everyone shares the same principle, which is, there is an undeniable existence and an undeniable presence of aliveness. And which permeates, which is, which is the ground in which all these different nuances, all the different little variations, the scientific viewpoint, the, the, the personal viewpoint or the, or the collective viewpoint or the, or the, you know, an analytical viewpoint. They're all valid, they're all playing themselves out in the, but our attention is, is the key here. Like it's all about the attention. Where, where is the attention going to go? Is it going to go from the scientific perspective?

Is it going to go from a personal perspective? Is it going to go from some other consensual reality perspective? Which one is true? None is true. And the attention oscillates until it doesn't, until it finds actual more, more, it gets to the crux of the matter. And the crux is it, it rests in its own aliveness. And the aliveness, the awareness, the, the sense of presence itself becomes the whole show rather than being like caught up in all the endless babbling. Um, the endless, endless ideas, endless stories, endless perspectives, and no matter how valid or, um, how much evidence or backing up, um, one particular viewpoint is, it's still existing as, as part of the whole.

Um, so that's my little take. Thank you. And. Yeah, that's beautiful. That's what I was trying to say. I couldn't, couldn't say it more eloquently. That's yeah. That's it. So Emmanuel, are you going to go first? I think he might've. Uh, maybe. Maybe. Maybe you can pull it up again. If not. If I'm, if I'm, if I'm on, I'm happy to be on. Oh, yes. We can hear you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And, uh, wonderful to see you all. Um, I guess just. Exploring the topic of, of animals. Um, this saga data, uh, uh, says that the self cares nothing for name and form.

Um, and I think in one of the conversations and I am that someone asked him about a child. You got burned by cooking oil. And blinded. And this saga data says it's all one thing, the event and the knowing about the event. It's all connected. It's not separate. Um, but I, I get stuck on the apparent suffering. For example, of, of animals, which comes into my field of attention. So. Seeing video footage of dogs in Thailand or Vietnam in tiny little cages waiting to be sort of killed and cooked footage of pigs in Australia being lowered into a concrete pit, um, to be gassed and they struggling to breathe all that kind of stuff.

Um, which comes into my field of attention. And then I'm concerned about it until my attention wanders onto something else. And I forget about it. Um, and it's happening, you know, apparently whether my attention is with it or not. And it's happening as we speak in a way, there's always the, the suffering and the not suffering present simultaneously. But when that comes into the field of attention and it doesn't seem to be much that I can do about it, what, what to do with that witnessing of a parent suffering? Um, is there a, is there a, yes. Yeah. Yeah. It's just, uh, I do get, I get stuck on it.

Um, yeah. Yeah. So I just came to, this is a beautiful question, Emmanuel and bless your heart. We all feel sensitive towards suffering. That is unnecessary animals, children, our loved ones, trees. Why don't we feel the same about bugs, mosquitoes? Why don't we feel the same about, you know, like Bob would say, you touch your face and how many families of a little insects you cripple or severe. You don't give a shit, don't you? Because you identify as a human. So only that, which is similar to you, you care about. You don't care about planets exploding out of existence. You only care about your dogs and cats, but how about rats?

Oh yeah, whatever. See, include everything. Open your heart wider. Open your heart so wide that every life form is included. Bacteria, virus, insect, planet. Just really uncompromisingly include everything. If you want to feel compassion, wonderful. Let it just blow you away. Compassion towards every species of every form of consciousness that ever existed. And let it kill you. Let it kill the mind. Let it melt it in, ah, yes, life is living on life. Like Nisargadatta said. And rather than subscribing to the mind, siding with that which resemble me. Because I'm identified as me. Just really open it. And see what happens then. You know, whether the dogs in Thailand are still in the cages or not.

Whether Julius Hooligans there in Turkey are still trying to break to the house. Who knows? But include them too. Every dream you ever had. Include that too. See how the processor will simply stop. Overload it with that imagination. Rather than giving yourself a little torture one at a time. Just blasts the whole lot. And let it land to the heart. There's something to do. Good. Good on you, Julia. I love you. Julia says, there is something to do. Yes. Beautiful. And that's why we're here. That's why we're here. For someone to say there is something to do. You're giving an advice. That's it. Bob was sitting here and saying, just relax.

Yeah. Yeah. But who is there to relax? Or look into. Investigate. Yeah. But there is no one there. Okay. Suit yourself. The truth is, all the pointers are presenting themselves out of themselves. There is no one there speaking them. And they offer certain frequency. If there is resonation, take it. If they are not, well, maybe the next one will do. And if none of it will, there is absolutely no sense of loss. Space is already clear. That which you are is already free from all suffering. Imaginary or real. And now, if you can actually just see if that resonates, that invitation to just open up, rather than selectively give your love to just that which shows up in the attention.

Just open that attention. Relax the attention. And let the whole world be included. The whole dream. And you will see when everything is included, suddenly Nisargadatta saying that, you know, when I'm everything, this is love. And then that everything is unprocessable. The mind shuts up. And then you land in the nothingness. And this is wisdom. And in between those, there is the flow of experiencing going on. But the moment mind steps in and says, no, no, I only care about dogs, not about rats. I only talk about cats, not about mosquitoes. Naturally, that's included. Well, I confess, this particular dream character absolutely adores every cat in the world, especially my two babies.

And I mercilessly kill mosquitoes. But as the space, I'm the presence witnessing the preferences of that body. And I don't stand in a position that this is right. No, it is just the appearance. So even if it feels like this is right and it's justified, and I don't want to close my eyes to the suffering, I don't want to be a psychopath who just turns the other way and pretends the polar bears are not dying there, that the seals are not jumping off the cliffs. And then you can include the 10,000 other things in that field of imagination. But how many things are you going to leave out?

Rather than just staying in the mind, direct experience again in the heart, nothing's excluded there. But there are no words, no mental images. So this is the beauty of like watching the mind and actually seeing, you know, like in Kat's example, you know, like the tendency to attend to the cats, like attention focuses on cats. Like it's not, you know, it's, well, I was going to say something. I might just not speak anymore. I was going to hear that John was going to speak earlier. John, yeah. He had his hand up. Hmm. And I think Cliff had something. Yeah. One or three minutes from every golem.

What was I going to say? Oh, just about suffering and thinking about, I like pain and pleasure exist in alternate, ultimately occurring patterns throughout the universe. And it can't be explained, but it is, it is as it is. And, you know, our minds are drawn to, are drawn to that, you know, to try maybe to understand it or to experience it in various stories. And it goes to dreaming. You know, some people can remember things out of their past that are extremely painful and they can't, you know, like a trauma or they, they can't get rid of this memory. It just keeps coming back or other people are not affected by it at all.

Or we're attracted to stories of suffering too, like in, in movies and horror films and, and, and stories of great pleasure too. And, and the mind can't help it, but it goes there. And then, you know, you, as Kat was saying, you, you think about, you know, um, your next door neighbor dying in pain or something, but care not for all the, the people that are rendered homeless in an earthquake or something like that on the, I think Ms. Agadada talks about that too. But, um, that fascination with news stories and looking for, Oh God, that's a terrible story. That thing that happened to that poor man.

You know, those children and, and in a way we, you know, the mind celebrates it in a strange sort of a way. Good. It takes me to, when I was in fourth grade, they talk about flies and mosquitoes. There was a kid there. He used to pull the wings off flies and burn them with a magnifying glass. It seemed really savage and a horrible thing to do, but nobody cares about flies. But, um, you know, it is a strange thing about the universe and the universal mind. Thanks Cliff. I might, um, there's, might just read, read some messages from, uh, Facebook. Um, Guati says, good morning all.

And Jeff says, well, said Dino and Bill. Hi Bill. Um, Bill says, got to keep this simple. It's not difficult. It's right in your face. Are you unaware right now? Bob, no philosophy to learn, no experience to achieve, no special state to maintain, just the question. And no need to turn whatever appears into another description of what you are. Beautiful. Thanks Bill. Beautiful. Beautiful. Thank you Bill. Yeah. Yeah. You could hop on Zoom Bill and would be absolutely wonderful to hear your voice one day again. Oh yeah. Maybe you should hop in. That would be just, what a treat. And John, would you like to, are you, are you still with us?

Yes, you are. Would you like to? Yeah. Um, it, it was actually kind of on what Bill was saying there. You know, I, I mean kind of coming back to the basics because I have this, um, cycle of feeling that there's some understanding and, um, you know, also just with my past experience with, uh, meditation, it's easy to meditate oneself into a place, which is very similar to, to these descriptions, but, um, there's still a conditional aspect, you know, and, um, just honing in on that. And that point that, um, that Bill just raised, um, that I know Bob would really, um, you know, yeah, hammer, hammer down on just to say, you know, you, you are aware and you know that you're aware you're present and you know, you're present and to get a very firm, uh, recognition of, of this.

So, um, and so on, and so on, and so on, and so on,

And that's something that I struggle with. That I, you know, I turn into thought stuff or, you know, it's just that the clarity for me isn't unconditional. So, yeah, I was just hoping we could speak to that and try to get into the nitty gritty on that, on those basics. Yeah. Thank you, John. And thank you, Bill, again. This is, yes, this is the crux of the matter. And Julia started with that too. And that was beautiful. This is just really, there is no way out. But bringing it all back, you know, the reality of existence.

If you look, maybe, I don't know if that's going to be helpful, but what Julia was saying, you know, you're present right now. She was present in a dream when the burglars were coming into the house. She was still that point in consciousness. The environment was different. There were burglars. She was in Turkey. Then she's right here right now. In the future, she may have a vision about her sitting in Hawaii Beach or whatever. She's traveling a lot. So those things, there is still one common denominator, the presence of consciousness. You are, and therefore the dream appears. You are what you are. You can't really tell because, you know, if you start defining yourself, then you're going down the rabbit hole.

In one dream, you might be something light that is flying. In another dream, you might be something heavy that can't move through the, like, you know, the sleep paralysis can't walk. In yet another dream. You might be in the midst of conversation in yet another dream, you know, like, but the presence, it doesn't change. It's always the same. The presence, even if you look back at the memories of being a child and you bring that memory, make it alive, that presence is there. That presence never changes. So that presence, the common denominator, that I am, before the Abraham was, I am, before the Big Bang, I am.

Where is the Big Bang if that body is a corpse? There's no experience of Big Bang. There's no experience of history. And thank you also for bringing up, you know, the ideas of how long memory the cat has. That's also just an idea that couldn't be there if not for the I am, if not for the sense of presence, the past, the future, the stories, Bob's pointers, nothing, if not for the sense of presence. And what can we say about it? Nothing. And can we deny it? It's like the whole dream comes onto the screen because I am. There is no way out. And now how could that be, you know, like, of course, the mind comes and start describing it or defining it.

I am. I am and that's my preferences. I am and this. I am but this. And then conditions come. But the first pointer in those in those 42 chapters is full stop. What's truth then? Full stop. I like that. Just this and nothing else. You know, it's suddenly in consciousness, the idea of being present, just this and nothing else, full stop. But it might be long before something else appears because that's that's the nature of the whole shebang is that that awareness is creating stuff all the time, you know, everything we've been talking about is a dream and a story in a way and will soon be forgotten or maybe remembered.

But it's always just this, nothing else here and now. And the only way to see it is is the full stop is to quieten it for a second and go, hey, this is it, you know, and then blah, blah, blah, splats up again. And I use the word conditional, but I suppose also like when people talk about the contrast both exists, like I've never seen it that way, because to me, it's just a macro view. It made this, you know, thoughts pop up that it's a macro world where just can see the tips of the icebergs and we can make something of it, do something with it, you know, but the thought always pops up here.

There's just the entire underneath that's never known about, you know, even the aliens probably don't know about it, you know, even there's probably no, you know, you know, there's probably no noticing in the universe that ever sees it all, you know, that, you know, I think that's where consciousness and awareness. There's to me are concepts to where there's imaginary noticing is going on, you know, you know, the, there's nothing to say there are notice things of any sort whatsoever. So basically if just everything that is ever there, all the swirls of energy, just to put a word on it, what, you know, if there even was like one great noticer of the universe, which I haven't seen any proof of, you know, these, there's just no way that there's any such thing as, as both things being true at once.

You know, there's no both, you know, this is no, it's like people get in New Zealand, people get confused about like biculturalism, they forget about multiculturalism, for example, but then you go deeper and it's just like, you know, it's just a giant activity. And that's it, you know, there's no being is only doing. And so just like la de la de la de la de la. And this is like, when you come to the full stop, there's also from, you know, here, there's an oil painting spread out in front to no thoughts about it. So it's pretty quiet and silent, but there's still that oil painting there.

And, and, you know, sort of snapshots, snapshot, you know, snapshot, and of course, this is like an activity, but later and a thought that comes up in a notion that's not even worded out of that painting. But in that full stop, where no, you know, discussion about that painting comes up. There is still no knowing, no knowing, no activity of knowing, activities, it's just la la la la la la la. Yeah, that's just, yeah, it's kind of what's there really. Punto. You know. Yeah. That's it. Okay. You know, you have the comment and you have. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, and I think, I think Bill has added something as soon as awareness is named as named is objectified is given any name, the pointer is lost.

Yeah. Ask the question. Don't answer it. Don't answer it. He says. Yes. And you had something to say when Tony was grabbing the phone. Oh, it's gone now. Oh, they've got there. All right. Okay. So. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you cat. Um, for having these sad songs. And, um, I feel it's a real honor, uh, to, to participate and witness, uh, be here experience here. Um, I, uh, I couldn't wait to rejoin you from our first time last week. And I've been thinking what I wanted to say, and it's pretty much the same as last week. And I hope you'll indulge me if I bring this up often because I'm, um, very open to, um, try to understand.

Um, so, um, yeah, I think about suffering a lot and, um, and I just want to, I'm not going to talk about suffering. I just want to, uh, make a conclusion for it. You know, when Christ or anybody is facing their death, um, or those Buddhist monks who poured gasoline on themselves, et cetera, all these, I don't want to remind, give people a bad feeling, but, you know, suffering could be just terrible. And, um, and that I, I would have a hard time, even if I knew I had a week to live, um, using, feeling at peace and thinking that I'm just consciousness. And I, um, and, uh, I, I'm not there yet, but I, I want to come back to just baby steps and something that William Peskina said in relation to what I mentioned last week.

So, so this week I had so many things that I had to plan and organize in my schedule. And I remember driving in my car and just thinking about these things and just placing, organizing them in my mind and then coming home and making a map to follow. And I want to offer, uh, to the group, I, I want to be able to convince myself that there's no me doing it, but it's so problematic because it, uh, even though, even though Bob has, everyone says that we don't create our thoughts, they come up. And then we take ownership of them thinking I thought that, but that is so hard in the face of the fact that for an hour and a half, I was mentally organizing all these things in my mind.

And it's hard to, uh, I don't know how I want to be able to convince myself that none. I don't know where to begin with this. It just seems like I did think all these things. I did plan it out. Okay. So that's basically my question. Thank you. Hmm. Yeah. You, you want to. No, you can like, but it, but it's fascinating, isn't it? Okay. Well, everyone, well, isn't it fascinating? Like watching, watching the mind and, and watching that, that energy, that, that thought, the idea of the convincer, the one that wants convincing is, is actually another, another one of those thoughts in the stream of thoughts.

Is it not? Uh, and, and, and they're all just appearances like, and, and one it's, it's like each, in each thought, there's an embedded idea that there's a me, myself, and I, especially in, in, in self, self referential thoughts. Um, and each, each one seems to be commenting on another one. Um, there seems to be like a sequence and, and a chain of events and a process, um, and yet they're all appearing in, in a spontaneous nowness. And so, so that, that energy or that thought, that idea of wanting to convince is part of that same stream. It's part of the, it's part of the same appearance as that, as that thought that appeared to plan, as that port, that thought that appeared to structure, that thought that appears to convince or wants to be convinced or needs to be convinced or, or, or feels that it will find peace by being convinced are all ideas.

And they're all the same ideas, different ideas, different nuances of thoughts appearing on that same screen. And attention is, is on, like the mind can't get itself out of the mind. The mind is causing this kind of suffering. Um, and so the mind can't actually get out of the suffering by using the same mental process that has actually created it. Yes. Oh, sorry. You're not second chance of my question. Um, I, I, I, what, I, I want to redirect the question, uh, the, the, the comment I made. Um, yes, I understand what you said very well, very, very, very well taken. But I, I, I'm, I'm really saying from the angle of trying to, um, and again, here I am using those words again, trying to and convincing and all that stuff.

But, but, but, you know, I, starting in the framework of my ego and mind so that I can transcend it into non-dualism is that, um, is that, um, that there is no me, I, my thoughts and I thoughts. Um, but it's hard to dispute that when I create such a plan over an hour. Or did those, did I, I must've done that because I can't see the environment. Just here. Uh, how did it know I needed to plan this visit and that visit? And there was other things there. Only I know that. Okay. Only I know that. Um, yeah, that's yeah. Brilliant. And thank you for your questions and you can ask them as often as you want.

And you know, ultimate answer, and this is really good, but we're still gonna have fun with it. It's what Bill says, you know, here, he says, ask the question. And don't answer. Stay in the mystery. I have no idea. What the heck? You know, I don't, I don't get it and, and stay with that because that is a beautiful invitation to the mystery, unknowability of it. But because this is an exploration and your question is, is, is valid. Absolutely. And it may be relatable. We still gonna give everyone a voice. How do they actually understand it? Because that's, that's the fun of it. That's the fun of exploration.

How do, how do I do it? How do I understand that I'm not the doer? If I've just done this, come on. Universe didn't know I needed to do this. Well, okay. So how have I even done it? Let's have a look. How did I do it? How did I actually make that plan? Hmm. Well, the thought occur, but yeah, how did I think that thought? Uh, well, I kind of didn't, but it occurred, but it was only relevant to the data available in that processor. So if that processor wasn't there, the thought couldn't have occurred. So it must be on me. Well, but if the environment was, wasn't there, the processor wouldn't have the thought, right?

So can we actually separate the processor from the environment? So who actually is the real doer in it if we can't separate it? So the whole universe is a doer now of that planning. I think the universe is using that particular voice, that speaker, that microphone to voice the plan of what to do in the garden. But this is the whole unified field of pure potentiality expressing through that particular one machine. But is it really a me, the one, the next thought that comes? No, there is layered mean inside. I am doing it, but okay. Wait a minute. How am I doing it? Uh, I don't quite know, but I know that I'm doing it, but how do I know it?

Well, because there is a thought, but how did I create that thought? Well, I didn't, but it is there and it's very convincing. So there is a feeling, there is a feeling of emotional charge and sense of conviction that I really did it. I really took that breath. This is on me. I did it. It's not that the planet exists. It's not that the gravity took part of it. It's not that the oxygen in the air is not that I'm in the room when I need to speak. And this is not, no, it's me. It's on me. See, if you can actually really draw the line, you can see the blending of all the influences of the 10,000 things that in the result of the computing, create that particular thought.

See how different the result of computation would be if you had something else for breakfast or if you had really shitty sleep and a nightmares, like nightmares, someone burgling into your house, you know, that could be a different outcome. So is it on you or is it on your nightmare or is it on your breakfast? You can see how that idea of doership is actually constructed for the navigational purposes. Because, you know, when you communicate to your neighbor, it of course makes sense that, look, you know, this, this ship, this vessel is moving through this areas and is doing this. It makes sense. It makes it smooth and easy.

But if you really, really look deeply, is that ship even possible? Is there even a possible possibility of movement if not for constant flux with the environment, the air exchange, the water, the food, the matter? Is there even a separate vessel that could actually move through those, navigate through those waters? And you see that that convincing idea of having that convincing sort of map of reality, that this is I, this is my map of reality. I'm navigating, I'm taking decisions, making choices. I'm responsible for what I say and do make sense within that dream. And you appreciate it. But you know the truth. Because when you look deeply, when you look underneath, you can see how that assumptions, assumption is made on very, very shaky ground.

Because you can't draw the line between me and the world. You are the world. You are the voice for that, for that whole flux of elements, particles, atoms. If this is the matter, again, this is, and I want everyone else to contribute to that, because this is really valid point. And in 10,000 ways that that question comes back, how do I do it? I even had a series of individual meetings with someone who considered themselves old, who was my age, and wanted to commit suicide and needed non-duality to convince him he's not the body, so he can do it without fear. That's not the role.

That's not what we have here to offer. So the consultations ended. Frankly, this is not a tool to patch up the me. And this is not something to be applied so the dream goes better or the fear goes away. This is not an agenda here. It is just basic reminder that the mind will have questions, will have more and more and more questions and opinions and perspectives and the ideas. Leave it as it is. Like Cliff was saying, you know, leave it as it is. There is a deeper truth beyond the mind, prior to the mind to be recognized, not to be taught, not to be added, to be recognized as already present.

You are already present. Thinking is already happening, just like heartbeat is already happening. And you're recognizing the effortlessness of that happening. You see how you are actually being lived. How, when the action is required, the thought arises in the system, in the response to the whole computation, whole universe contributing, and the action happens, or it doesn't. And then the narrative comes, oh, I should have, would have to, you know, that's part of it, part of the dream. But generally, there is no doing required. It is just the plain basic recognition. Yeah. And you've sparked a few comments as well on Facebook Live. Jyoti says, Laird, it helps me to distinguish planning from the outcome.

Mind can plan for hours. But what actually happens is outside of mind's content. Sometimes each item planned may event eventuate while other items, while other times it may not. And Bill says, don't try to prove that you don't do anything. Look for the one who supposedly does it. And Emmanuel has also added something. I wish to be free to go anywhere in the dream. The police were giving CPR to a sheep, but the sheep did not make it. Thank you. Thank you anyway, Karma Police. That was beautiful. Yes. Oh, yeah. Yes. Oh, you didn't want to. I thought you wanted to say something. I'll say something.

Yes. No, pass it. No, pass it. No, pass it. Give it to Dean. That's okay. Well, I can just say like that idea of if you make it very practical and you wait for the next sound that's coming. Can you know what the next sound is going to be ever? Yes. Wait for the next sound. Can you tell me what the next sound is going to be? If you go to turn on, you know, some music, you really absolutely know. Can you know what it's going to be ever? Can you know the next sound? And what about your thought? So what about the next thought?

Do you ever really know what it's going to be? If it is, why don't you choose good ones all the time? Is it possible to know the next thought? So there's a thought that pops up and then there's another thought that pops up that says I'm having that thought. So the I doesn't even exist. It's just another thought. But what's there before the thought? And this is what's there when you were a child, when you were, there's something in you that was looking through your eyes when you were two and ten. And fifteen and twenty. That's something that's never changed, isn't it? Do you recognize that?

So what is it that hasn't changed? What's there for every thought? It's not an I. It's not another thought. And so I think the big problem is everyone expects a big bang like I did as well. Once you get this, it's going to be. There's nothing special about it. It's always been there. So that's that's the disappointment in it all. It can't possibly be just this. What if it was? And what if you didn't have a judgment on it? And wouldn't that be freedom? So it's a it's a practice if it's stepping back into what it is that is always there that doesn't change. I'm just recognizing because it's like a fish in water, a fish doesn't know it's in water.

It's always there. So it's not special. Mine's always looking for danger. Mine's always looking to protect. But just like a fish in water, you don't recognize that this is always here, but it's always been. I just start noticing what it is that's always been there. So when a thought pops up, say, what was here before that? What's after? What hasn't changed? What's not changed by the thought? It's a constant practice because we've been conditioned to believe the mind and trust the mind and follow the mind. Yeah, so. Beautiful. Thank you. Yeah. So what helped me with that struggle of am I doing it and all that sort of stuff?

Of course, I was the doer. I thought that asking those questions like they seem really simple. First of all, like does the thought I see actually see? Do you have to think? I see. I see. I see. To see. And I hear. I hear. I hear. To hear. No, you don't have to think or do anything to see or hear. It's just happening. And then is the thought I'm aware actually the awareness? And I realized, no, it's not the awareness. And it's the thought I think actually do the thinking as has been well explained. You can't possibly take credit for thinking because you wouldn't think anything unpleasant or you just think great, exciting thoughts all day, but you can't choose your thinking.

And then the big one for me was just the thought I do actually do anything. I thought, well, it must be me that does the doing. And then I realized that I don't choose to do lots of things. They just happen, you know, like scratching my head at the moment. Did I think anything to do that? No, it just happened. And the thinking that goes before it just happens. Like the thought I'm going to move my finger actually happens before I move my, before my, the intentionality was there, but I didn't, I didn't create that intentionality. And in a way I can't understand it because the whole process of thinking and the mind and all that stuff is contained in the awareness itself.

So to try and get my mind around the awareness of what's causing it all is, is an impossibility. It's like an ant trying to understand how I'm driving the car or something like that. It's, it's outside the possibility of conceiving it. That's the way I, I think about it or that's why I see it now is all this is happening and the mind struggles to label it and take credit for it or understand it, but it, it can't do it. It says I'm causing it. I've caused all this suffering or I've done the wrong thing or I've done the right thing. Look at me. And yet these are just more, more thoughts that can't be explained.

Leave it there for me. Yeah. Perfectly said. I had all these poems, which were, I looked at them about eight years ago, seven, eight years ago. Look at them recently thought, oh, this shit. And then recently again, I looked again and thought, oh, not so bad. And I could fix them all. But this is probably the least, least. Just read it slowly because sometimes speak. I always speak very fast. It's probably the crappiest of a lot still, but it just is very relevant to today. So this just follows the impressions as they arose. It's not very perfect yet. Okay. So I followed the eye to the center of a thought with eye in it to find that it dissolved and was gone.

The core of every imagined action I had taken, I had taken, was hollow. What was left became so light, just the periphery. What I was, was now pure expansion and rest. So the next. Yeah. Yeah. You see this. Yeah. You're fine. You're fine. No, no. It's a lesson. Thank you. I loved what you were saying and what it made me express now is that what we the trouble is we put boundaries upon everything and we've made a prison with whatever is here the contents in which we're seeing the word is the boundary we put upon it so our senses are limited in the fact that what I'm seeing if I'm seeing the word placed upon it that is boundary and also the sense of hearing if I'm labeling whatever I'm hearing so the senses are limited in the fact that we put boundaries upon what is now if we're aware of what's saying what's hearing what's feeling what's tasting we realize that awareness is not bound now the only way out of this prison even a thought is bound by the words that we place upon it so the only way out of all of this is to be aware

And realise that we are aware.

And that anything, any label that we put on anything is limited. I think Bob sometimes said, can you remember your birth? And what he was pointing to is the fact that you can only go back so far when you were told at two what you were. And that's really when the prison started to seem real. Before we were born, what did Bob used to say that the ovum and the bear refused? And what he was pointing at is that the intelligence energy, we are not who we think we are. We are actually everything and everyone here. It's the same intelligence energy that shapes and forms everything.

The tree outside is the same intelligence energy. We are no different from nature. The only thing that we are, the only reason we think we are different is because we are putting words upon which cannot be named. And the pointings are trying to get out of the prison that were built. Kat, Dean, everyone in this room is pointing towards something that cannot, it's just boundless. It can't be. We're just trying to get out of something that's not real. And it's just, yeah, I don't know how else to say it. But Bob, I guess he was a beautiful expression of the fact that pointing to who we are.

And he was just trying to get, I don't know, I'm just ranting in the episode. Yeah, that's terrific. I was just thinking what you said stimulated me. Most important things about living can't be explained, like life can't be defined by the mind or thought. The idea of life or living can't be explained by the idea of life or living can't be defined. It can't be explained. Love can't be explained. It just is. You know, being can't be explained. It just is. And these fundamentals of existence, existence itself can't be explained. So the mind can't be explained by the mind. So the mind can't deal with that.

Can deal with objects and ideas and things like that. But the absolute fundamentals can't be explained by the mind. It was interesting. It was interesting. The other day I was listening. I listened to the science show and philosophy shows are talking about time and the origins of the universe and life is seemingly programmed to happen. And I'm talking about computers and life generating swamps or what caused humanity to grow and evolution. There must be a planner. There must be some force that something there creates. Is there a creator and all this sort of stuff. And talking about billions of the shortest time span with some sort of quantum vibration where there's a billionth of a billionth of a billionth of a second.

And what was what was there before the big bang and all police scientists are talking about this. And I'm thinking. It doesn't matter how they explain it all or try to explain it. It reminds me how philosophers and religious brains of the 16th century were all spent their time trying to mathematically work out how many angels could dance on the head of a pin. It seems like that in a way that all this discussion about who created the universe or is it what happened before the big bang or is there multiple universes or all this sort of stuff. It occupies the mind but still gives us it's no further to understanding anything that's true in the universe.

How many calls are there? How many calls are there? So there's one that we've created. There's one that we've created as the me. Another one that wants to get rid of the me. Another one can be sex, alcohol, drugs. And it's endless because nothing can trouble you except your own imagination. So your mind is endless. That's all it's that's all it does. So it's creating. It's creating. So if if I believe myself to be someone. I'm I will do anything to try and get rid of that me. So I will create a God to get rid of the eye that I'm believing in. Yeah. And it will keep going.

It will create. Right. Sticks and alcohol. Anything. Iterations are endless. The objects are endless. Iterations are endless. Who does that? The eye. The eye. The God does that. I am God. And that's the point. It pops up. That's a joke. That's a joke. That's a joke. That's that's. Yes. Yeah. It's just the end of us. It's the pure creations. The creativity is the create ink. You see the whole. The whole idea that there is someone that is being rather than the being. Someone that is seeing rather than just pure capacity of seeing. Someone that is thinking rather than just pure capacity of thinking of the capacity is expressing the infinite creativity of that pure potentialities expressing through this processor through this piece of mouth.

And it is just create ink. There is no little mini me that is doing it. There's no little mini God that is creating other gods. It's just create ink. And it was beautiful. What Ben actually reminded us that, you know, in the beginning was the word. That's the beginning of creation. That's the that's the and Julia sometimes brings it up, you know, the eating the fruit from the tree of good and evil and starting differentiating. This is good. This is bad. Losing the paradise of oneness. Because now I am here and I am not out there. The vision. What a beautiful even the meats of creation, even the philosophers pointing back is as if, you know, the universe being one, winking at itself, having fun with itself, pointing through 10,000 ways.

I think Dino has the word. Yeah. Go on. Word was God. In the beginning was the word and the word was God. Anthony's got some comments. Anthony, watch, watch the afterthought. Thoughts, thoughts can't think. They can't think themselves out of charged thoughts. Thinking happens. Thinking about thinking happens. Getting caught up in thoughts happens. It's okay. Between the thoughts, just take the time to let it be. And then he says, best things in life are free. Laughing out loud. Everything has that freedom without that label. The label limits everything. Hmm. Which is what you're saying. And, and that label, you know, this, this cage is prison.

This whole thing is a, is a, is a cage of concepts. It's an invisible cage. It's, it's not a cage. It's, it's a completely, and, and yet it feels, might feel and seem so, you know, spent a lifetime bound by these, these, these, this cage, these, these walls, these, these bars that are so rigid. It's like the truth. I am here and that is there and I'm going to fix this. And make this better. And, and, and my beliefs are right. And my beliefs are true. And my beliefs are yes. And, and yours are wrong. Like yours are obviously wrong. Cause mine are right. And, and the whole thing is, is a, you know, it is a joke.

Like it, but it's, it's a very serious joke. If you're caught in it at that time, it's, oh, this is the truth. Um, until it's not until it's wow. What a conceptual thing. What a, what a story. And who made it? How was it created? Who, who, where did, and all the, all that you can say is that it's just appeared. It just appeared. And what does it appeared on the screen of aliveness itself of life? I think, you know, like Bob would start the meeting often, you know, saying, start with the fact that you're already that. And because, because being caught in that cage and trying to dig yourself out, like it's, it's fraught with endless, with, with more imaginary walls, hidden behind other walls, behind other walls, behind trap doors and behind, you know, swamps and pits.

And so, so because it's, it's, it's a conceptual cage. So you're using more concepts to try and un conceptualize a cage. It doesn't even make sense. So starting with the fact that you already that. So what was he pointing at? What was he sharing? What was he inviting everyone to, to sort of bask in immediately before, before a whole mental gymnastics begin is like that. What is that? What is that? That is that you undeniable sense of presence. Your undeniable beingness itself. And in that, like there is no, without a thought, there is, where's the limit? Where's, where's time? Where's me? Where's you? Where's this?

Where's that? Where's good? Where's bad? Where's up and down? Where's right and wrong? Um, it's just that. And that really is, is this. Disappointing answers. Yes. And, and what Michael was actually saying, you know, waiting for fireworks. This is not good enough. What is this? This is just another thought, isn't it? It's just another thought. What Dean was just saying, you know, prior to that thought and Michael said it, you know, what was prior to that thought? This is not good enough. This is not good enough. Come on. That that's it. Well, how about? Yes. How about yes to this? And all the ideas that it should be different.

It should be brighter. I should be smarter, younger. This other people should love me more. I should agree with me. I should, you know, or there should be, you know, the ideas that people have about enlightenment. Wow. The ideas that we might have subscribed to unconsciously. I'm going to be fulfilled. I'm never going to feel negative emotions. I'm going to feel that there's no one there. I'm going to feel that the sense of presence is going to be gone. That's not all those ideas. One rubbish, one ideas without them. Full stop. What's left? So you mean, you mean like my whole, all my Kundalini energies are not going to hit this certain point at a certain time and where full explosion and I am one unified consciousness and explode into bliss and start singing and birds will start landing on my hand and butterflies.

Yes. Yeah. That is when your chakras aligned and open, you have to wait, wait for the future. Till your chakras get aligned. Till you get your, uh, recognition from 10 Zen masters till the cows will, will, what, what's the saying? Something about the cows do something. Yeah. But, but, but. Cows come home. Yes. Wait till the cows come home. Wait till you get the right diet. Till your body is purified. Till your mind is purified. 20,000 hours of TM and the mantra, the other, other type of meditations. And then maybe in the seventh light lifetime from now, you will be eligible. What is it? This one mental image.

This is just a one mental image. Check it. Full stop. Where are the chakras ideas of diets, seven lifetimes? Where is it? If you just apply that full stop out of curiosity, then the next thought will come immediately after. Yes, but that's not good enough. That's another thought out of the full stop. And doesn't mean that you should, you should stay in a full stop and never have a thought. What a joke. Cliff elaborated on that. Exactly. This is the ground in which everything, all ordinariness, brilliance, no one's making a mockery of chakras or anything like that. Everything is included. Everything is included. And like saying it's ordinary or brilliant or whatever, descriptions of any description are still appearing in this presence, in this thatness or thisness of the immediacy.

And wow, that's when the show gets really, you know, really fascinating because everything you can see, the oscillations are all dualistic. They're all two ends of the same stick. Everything is, the whole appearance is a dualistic appearance. And it's, it's actually like fantastic. Like what, what, what, and that's the only way that it can appear. And they're using the term appearance again, because it's an appearance. It's an appearance. And at that point, yeah, that's when the, like the whole cycle of the whole idea of birth and death and the whole struggle to be, to be someone and become something and whatever, like just how, how can that, where they're all, they're all appearances too.

Yeah. In that appearance, all those, you know, fears and desires and pleasure and pain and all that stuff that'll preoccupy us at times will, will come. But knowing it's an appearance gives it the freedom to move, which is a great benefit in being able to see that that is, that is the case rather than being bogged down in beliefs and ideas, but you know, that's the freedom. That's the freedom. You know, nothing to, if you realize there's nothing to do and no one to do it, there is a certain freedom in that, even though the doing will continue to be done and will be perceived that someone is doing it.

You know, someone's chopping wood and carrying water. You know, that is you. It's like attention frees itself up from the, from the, from following all the, from believing, like the energy, charged energy of this is, this is real. This is who I am. This is absolutely. It's like, oh, hang on. No, attention is focused on the aliveness itself. Yeah. On the beingness itself. On the, on the actual. Wow. The wellness. So. Yeah. Loving to be. Like Julia was saying, you know, she's quoting Nisargadatta for a moment, you know, love it all. Yeah. Or none of it. It doesn't really matter whether you love, love it all or none of it, because then you have no position to be taken and there is no, you constructed to take a position.

But the natural love of being, you know, suddenly, naturally all the beautiful, colorful ideas of chakras. Wow. Can't you not love it? It's beautiful. I wasn't trying to mock any of those ideas. They just so amazing. But then you see them from the point of freedom and appreciation. You appreciate the whole colorful appearance, your colorful dream. You even appreciate the nightmare you wake up from, you know, and the sheep is still dead. And, and you still think what Emmanuel was saying, and you still thank the karma police. Yes. The appreciation is kind of a natural state. It is the satchitananda, being, knowing, loving to be.

Yeah. But, you know, I was just thinking, you know, when you see, well, the, my, my children, when they're born, that they haven't, there's no cage, but the loving to be is there already. You know, you can see the awareness, everything is fully functioning yet. They haven't been, they haven't been indoctrinated into the cage yet, but, um, it's just naturally pouring. Yeah. That's like, because at that stage, they're not, um, the thought's not telling them that they're seeing, hearing. Oh, yeah. Well, they're confined to a body or anything like that. So they're not really. Bob always pointed out that. So the thought can't, um, yeah, I can't really exactly what he used to say.

What did he used to say about that? No, with the senses and the thought, he was, yeah. The thought can sink. That's it. The, the, the thought I see cannot actually see the thought. I think can't actually think. It's just the thought arising. There's thought itself. What is it? It's like Tony says, I like the way Tony described it. It's like a line of letters line of words. It's a thought. It's a line of code. You know, that's, that's what it is. It doesn't even have the device inside to think. It can't do anything at all. It's just an appearance appearing in the dream. In that conscious awareness that, that, that they want.

Can you pop up one word at a time? Yeah. Ooh. When it's been caught here. It's like a nub comes up with just, there's a knowing of what the thought's about. And then get a oil painting of a little light red nub for some reason. And then, then like, not always like sometimes it was caught, you know, the words will then pop up one after the other describing that notion that showed, but have caught. And, and there's been, and it's also been caught like partway through and then kind of like, and not continuing that, you know, like also an annoyance at the fact that those, those thoughts keep coming up in the past.

They will show too, but yeah. And then, and that'll just cut and finish. And that would be it. You know, think about the, you know, about children and being the awareness before the word or all that sort of stuff. Yeah. It's not just there when they're born, it's, it's there before they're born too. And it's not just, you think, oh yeah, in the uterus there's awareness too, but the awareness is there before they're even conceived. You know, it is, it's universal. It, it, it, it precedes everything, you know? So, so it's our awareness and I got it when I was born, but that's not true.

Yeah. Yeah. The word is deceiving. I think I actually really liked when Julia highlights, maybe Julia, you want to do it when you highlight the intelligence energy, you're like, no, come on. You still upset? I'm sorry. No, I don't want to. Oh, okay. Okay. Okay. Yeah. I, I really liked the way you say, you know, when, when you highlight that Bob, instead of the word awareness would, would use the energy, the intelligence intelligence. Yeah. Come on. Come, please. All I can say is that, um, I used to hear the expression, I am awareness. And I can understand what you're saying, at least, you know, that the cells, I bet the cell has an sense of being, doesn't have the words I am or the sense of being the cell, which is, or the subatomic particle or whatever it is.

You don't think there, there's a sense of, probably even has a sense. It doesn't have the words for it, but it's a knowing. Right. Yeah. There's a knowing of, of this, this knowing of being that, that seems that's probably there. But what I was hearing is that everything is awareness and that there's just this awareness. And I'm like, well, how the fuck is that star aware? I feel like I can't see how stars are wearing. I'm like, what's it a wearing of? I mean, like, how is it wearing or knowing anything? I mean, it doesn't make sense to me. I couldn't, couldn't like put that in the box and make it fit the puzzle piece.

It just didn't help me. But when I heard the expression intelligence energy, then I can like, all right, can you think of anything at all that exists without that energy, without anything at all, anything at all. And then there's an, after I started to learn about actually now I can. Yeah. Yeah. There's a space that the energy appears on, you know, that, that is beyond the energy. You know what I mean? But without that space, without the energy, you wouldn't have the space and without the space, you wouldn't have the energy. So that's where the Shiva Shakti dance thing may also fit. But that's also energy that that's energy too.

So there's only that energy. And even, but the space, well, is what the energy appears on. It's like, but like, if you look at a, a wave on a graph, you see the wave, that's the energy, but then you see whatever the wave is appearing on. Okay. Okay. That's before the energy. I've read a book. Um, the title really appeared to me. It's a good book. It's written by an astrophysicist who comes to non-duality. He was born a, born a Hindu and he left all that behind him when he studied and all that sort of stuff. And then trying to understand, understand the universe in a way came back to non-duality and what he'd learned as a child.

But the, the book's called the self, the self-aware universe. And that sort of struck me that the whole thing is self-aware. It's not just our minds. See, I should have read that book because I couldn't like see where's the star aware. Yeah. Right. But the whole thing is aware. Yeah, no, I can see that. I mean, I understand that and I can see that, but I was like, and when I was first starting to explore this stuff, I was just like, well, I don't get it. I don't get it. Like there was wanting to figure it out still happening. Yeah. Right. Right. And, and I don't need to figure it out anymore.

But there was a, there was a, what's the eye that does? No, I don't care. We were brought up to believe that the consciousness is in here. I think. Yeah, for sure. Yeah. You know, that, that it's all happening in the brain. Yeah. You know what I mean? Or in this body within this form. But I like to use this, like I'll come to people and I'm like right now, I'm not touching you, but you can maybe feel the heat, you know, with that's, that somehow we think the skin's the boundary. Yeah. But, but it's, it can go beyond. I think it's, it's animating. I'm not doing anything.

There's just the, the heart's beating is happening and I'm not doing that. I can't make that happen. And you can walk down the street and just realize that everybody in the street is the same. Fucking puppets. It's a movie and it's kind of fun to see it this way. It helps. It helps. But I, yeah, the, the, the, from, you know, the, the intelligence energy, seeing that there's only just energy. There's only that. Everything is that it's just that. And then it's just the mind that says higher energy, your energy, my energy, low energy, bad energy, good energy, this energy, that energy. It separates the energy and it's all happening in thought.

And without the thought, there's just the, just, just one energy, just this, just, just energy. Yeah. That's a way of seeing things, a way of explaining things is, is exactly like you say. And sometimes, you know, that thought is energy. Everything is, is, is that energy. And what's the, like, you're just so clearly expressing what's the energy appearing on, you know, is it appearing on anything? It's, it's, that's when there's the nothing and the something, it's like nothing vibrates as energy into something. And yet they're, they're not separate from each other. They can't be separate. They're the same, the same thing. Yeah. It appears separate.

You know, if you look at it, it looks separate, but it's just, it's still all the same thing. But your dress is, um, expressing 3D energy. If you put the video on her dress, it's expressing like 3D energy or swirling energy, but beyond, you know, there might be quantum energy. There might be a whole lot of other energy expressions beyond that, but that's, you know, one of the conceptions we often see, but we don't say, you know, to many people, that would be too spiritual, you know? Yes. So even science backs that up, like the collapse of the wave function. There has to be consciousness.

Like matter doesn't even exist. It exists as a probability of existence. That's right. And then when consciousness interacts with it, it's either there or it's not. And then sometimes they say it's both there and not there. That's it. Yeah. And the universe splits, the universe splits. So it's there in one universe and it's not there in another, and you go off in different directions. But just like. Yeah. It is. And see, and this is really what the duality boils down to. The whole non-duality. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Okay. We're going to give you a voice. Yes. Yes. Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to, because I don't, I wanted to thank everybody because I'm processing all these really illuminating comments and I realize even though I bring the same question to the satsang.

And it's important. It's worth all the discussion we're having for me to dive deep into it. But I see it doesn't, for me now, it's not going to the heart of the matter. A lot of things that were said, that is the key for me to feel freedom, is to recognize a lot of these things. For example, that I was opening up by saying, I'm thinking this and this for three hours and have a plan. But then realizing that my thoughts cannot explain or experience awareness, that awareness is experiencing that. And that just gave me a lot of freedom. So thank you, everybody. Yeah. That's beautiful.

Yeah. Beautiful. And the thought, I organize, can't organize. That's true. Yes. And yeah, that was beautiful. And yes, bring every question. We really appreciate it. They're wonderful conversation starters. And even though, like Bill was saying, and Bill, if you're still with us, I hope you're going to hop in on Zoom and say it out loud. Ultimately, there is no answer in the mind. And ultimately, at some point, the questions will keep coming up and we just laugh them away. Don't answer them anymore. But in this, we are really having a lot of fun exploring 10,000 ways in which pointers can be used to silence the mind by answering the questions and reminding it again that the mind is not who you are, not what you are.

It is just the arising duality, that energy arising. And yes, I was just going to say, we didn't hear Jane today and we almost at the end. And Jane, would you like to unmute? Yeah, it was great conversation. Thanks for the questions and thanks for everybody's comments. It was great. Very juicy. Thank you, Jane. And thank you, everyone. Thank you. Hey, Emmanuel, David, Anand, and I can't see John anymore, but thank you, everyone. I've got a brief comment about dreams. Like, you know, I had the opposite kind of dream from Julia. Like last night, I had a dream where actually like quite organized thoughts were popping up one after the other and like regular kind of things noticed as of in my daily life, the same way it happens during the day.

And it was quite surprising. And there was like a kind of remembering of that after as well. And it just felt like doing a day and a dream almost. And it was like, wow, yeah, there's another way to just make it all come down to one point of being the same thing, you know? Yeah. Yeah. And again, I'm just going to say it. Guys who are with us on Facebook live, you can see there again, if you feel more comfortable not showing up, you can have your camera on. But you might not just consider to join us via Zoom. If not, we are absolutely happy to include you via comments and thank you for all the comments.

Most of all, thank you guys for having, having. Bye. Bye.